I'm a Jason Campbell guy. Always have been. But even I was amused this week by the suddenly revisionist history that suggested Campbell was some sort of quarterbacking savant victimized by frequent coaching turnover and a miserable offensive line. I mean, I like the guy. I like given the right circumstances he can be a fine quarterback. But changing to the west coast offense doesn't have any affect on a QB's ability to throw a deep pass. And a makeshift offensive line doesn't render one unable to audible at the line of scrimmage.
I mention this tonight because Campbell may be in the final throes of his Redskins career and, if that's true, I'm not going to be too torn up about it. I think he should be the quarterback next year while the team nurtures a young talent or sets its sights on trade bait/free agency for 2010 or 2011, but it's not going to be a travesty if he's not.
Tonight wasn't Jason Campbell's fault, but he didn't do anything to help it out. And that's the thing with him; he's almost never the difference maker. He's adequate enough to do the right things for the right team, but he's not a guy who's going to go out and win them for you. He's like a poor man's Eli Manning.
This didn't stop Malcolm Gladwell from hilariously suggesting that Campbell could be as good as Eli's brother:
Everyone always says what an incredible advantage it has been for Peyton Manning to have had the same offensive coordinator and the same offensive system his entire career. Football offenses are so complex now that they take years to master properly, and having one system in place from the beginning has allowed Manning to capitalize on every inch of his talent. On the other hand, someone like Jason Campbell has had a different offensive coordinator in virtually every season of his pro and college career (and I'm guessing he'll get another this offseason). I'm not convinced that it's possible to say, with certainty, that Campbell has less ability than Manning. I'm only sure we can say that Campbell has not been in a situation that has allowed him to exploit his talent the way Manning has. We just don't know how good he is capable of being -- and we may never know.
Oh, I'm quite convinced that it's possible to say, with certainty, that Campbell has less ability than Manning. That's no knock on Campbell. There are maybe five guys in history who have as much ability as Peyton.
But this is provocative for the sake of being provocative. Stick to pop psychology, Malcolm. If the point is that the NFL is the sport in which players are most dependent on teammates and coaches, that's not exactly groundbreaking theory. Tom Brady isn't Tom Brady if he's not on the Patriots. Jerry Rice would have been just another great receiver without Joe Montana and Steve Young. But you put Andre Johnson on the field with Peyton Manning and all of a sudden maybe he's the best of all-time.
That doesn't happen in the other sports. Kobe might not have won titles without Shaq or Pau Gasol, but his individual greatness didn't change when they weren't there. And great players slum it on lousy teams in baseball all the time.
About tonight's game? Eh, I don't really care. My mom said it's the first time ever she didn't watch the second half of a game. I didn't either. I played foosball for most of the later half of the game. It's just not worth watching.
This may have been a good thing though. Now Bruce Allen won't think that this team, as currently constructed, is anywhere near being an elite team. Frankly, I wouldn't mind if he keeps Orakpo, Cooley, London and Devin Thomas and guts the rest of the roster. (What about Haynesworth? I don't really care to root for him. He's great and can change the game inside, but he's a punk, takes too many plays off and is probably resented by the younger guys on the team. I want to like the team I root for. If I had a guy like Haynesworth or Jay Cutler, I'll root for them and cheer them, but I won't like it as much)
So, that's that. A 33-point loss to a heated division rival. A 4-10 overall record, a lame duck coach who should have been canned in September looking more clueless than Wade Phillips, a new GM and an owner who is more hated in this city than Aaron Burr. (We still hate Aaron Burr, right?) Hell of a start to Christmas week.